Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Myrtle's Doctrine of God - How to Let God Help You

              In the World of Mary Caroline, God is held as Father, with the appropriate third person pronouns to a male figure-head. “God - my Father and your Father…” is reflected throughout the works of Myrtle Fillmore. “We are beginning to to learn that life is our gift from the Father…” are words that were shared with confidence and assurance. Mary Caroline experienced a strong and caring father in her youth, so this representation carried no negative aspects beyond her ability to resolve. This is true for myself, also, but I understand that this representation of God as Father is troublesome for many others, so troublesome that it could prevent them from pursuing this God in their lives. For some, the idea of God as Father is punitive, as their human father was punitive, or ill-natured, as their human father was ill-natured, or worse.


     The representation of God as Father also strongly suggests a separate Father-God figure or essence, something separate and apart from us, although available to us. This is not the understanding I carry of God-Spirit. The practice of “naming” God as He, She, or Friend is problematic for my brain to embrace. It is, again, holding God as something separate from me, something “name-able”. I do not believe we possess the ability to fully comprehend God, so how can we “name” God beyond 
G-O-D? Yes, the God described by Mary Caroline/Myrtle dwells everywhere, therefore dwells within all.  However, both images are difficult to embrace at the same time.  Is God separate or not? The image presented through Myrtle’s works is problematic, yet most probably a product of the time in which Myrtle lived. It was generally accepted that God was referred to as He and Him. A deviation from that custom - at that time - may have been too radical to be accepted.

     There is also the subject of “…His plan for us…” Myrtle often refers to God’s plan and for us to “do His will.” This may be viewed as predestination, which is an issue for many individuals. It would be an issue for me if I felt that was the message being communicated. Myrtle goes on to explain that “the real purpose of your life is to express the creation of God…”, but the verbiage goes on to hint of God’s plan. God’s plan and God’s will are difficult concepts to wrap our heads around. Many are “turned off” by this apparent lack of free will.  I do not believe that was Myrtle’s intention or her doctrine. Myrtle goes on, in Chapter Three, to describe in detail the wonders and the “greater freedom of expression” one will experience when consciously united with God Mind. Freedom and free will do not align up with predestination. Therefore, Myrtle’s doctrine of God included freedom and free will.

     Life can be good and Myrtle urges seekers to unify their “spirit, soul, and body in harmonious spiritual living here and now.” Life can be good now, here on earth. We don’t have to suffer and shouldn’t suffer during our earthly life, expecting rewards after death. God is good - here and now.  In our lifetime. 

All quotes come from Myrtle Fillmore, How to Let God Help You (Unity Village, MO: Unity School of Christianity, 1956), 14-17.

(every time I cut and pasted this document from Page to this Post, the footnote numbers and footnotes disappeared. There does not appear to be a way to insert the footnotes from this format)

7 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Daybree, I am glad you brought up the issue of "God the father." My understanding is that the relationship between Myrtle and her father was a bit more complex.

    There are two stories that I have read about how Myrtle got the name Myrtle. The first one is that her father was a very straightlaced businessman. When he came home from work he would pick up his little daughter and swing her around, saying: "There is my Myrtle Lee." And from this came the name Myrtle. The second story I have read is that Spirit told Myrtle that her name was Myrtle.

    But there are other stories about her father. Myrtle's older sister stood up in her father's church and told the congregation that she could no longer worship in such a small minded situation. Then the older sister walked out of the church and never returned to it. The father told the older sister to go back and apologize. She wouldn't and instead left home.

    Thus, I think for myrtle the word Father was a mixed bag. Her use of the word father in terms of God might has more to do with the social conventions of her time period than with for metaphysical understandings.

    It is interesting to see how even advanced thinkers can still be very much product of their times. For example, when it comes to Paul, he can say something with such spiritual insight-- and then in the next breath he can sound like such a reactionary (or product of his times).

    I always enjoy your shares.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You write: "Myrtle often refers to God’s plan and for us to 'do His will.' This may be viewed as predestination, which is an issue for many..."

    Some might find is a stretch to extract predestination from the idea of God's will, but I think your point is well taken. If everything is preordained, as the inexorable Will of God must be, that means freedom is either an illusion or merely permission to dally along the route to an ineluctable conclusion. A possible theological solution to the problem of free will which preserves Divine Omniscience might be to suppose God does not know the choices we shall make or their outcome. A grander view of Omniscience might allow that Divine Mind understands ALL choices and ALL options which flow from an infinite set of freely chosen circumstances, but not the specific choices before we make them. This is an interesting thought-problem, but one could argue its resolution is probably far above human comprehension.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Daybree-
    You raise an interesting issue about Myrtle’s use of God as Father, relating that relationship to the one she had with her own father. Knowing very little of Myrtle’s early home life, I can't go there. What I heard in her language was more in line with Jesus’ approach to God as Father. Was Jesus transposing his relationship with his earthly father onto his spiritual father? I don’t think so. Much as I loved my dad, he had human limitations and was never my unfailing source. I inherited good and some less-than-good from him, whereas I get only good from God. As for “God’s plan for us,” I doubt Myrtle was talking about predestination or any lack of free will on our part. She said we’ll get to that knowledge at some time. The choice was ours about when we come to it. This reminded me of A Course in Miracles statement of it being a required course… when we take it voluntary.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Daybree,
    I haven't had internet service for a few day's. Had I read your interpretation on Myrtle's definition of God I wonder how that may have influenced my own interpretation... It is interesting to see the varying points of view especially since we've been given the same material from which to study and interpret.
    I agree with you that Myrtle is hard to interpret and her work isn't even as old as the bible... Interesting perspective isn't it. How is one to really know what she meant when everything seems left up to interpretation.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Daybree,
    I wonder if Myrtle's use of the word Father is no more complicated than that was how Jesus often referred to God. "Our Father which art in Heaven ... " I too am uncomfortable with the way she uses it but I don't have the same concern over how it shows up in Scripture. Maybe I'm just imposing my beliefs and concluding, she's a "relatively" modern person and therefore should have known better. Or, maybe her theology did consider God to be a father figure. I don't have an answer, just more questions at this point. ;-) Doug

    ReplyDelete
  7. Did Myrtle Believe in a Separate God ? A great question! You raise a good point. Did she believe in a separate, masculine God or as you so eloquently stated, would speaking other wise have been such a strong deviation from that culture's custom that, it may have been too radical to be accepted. It's hard to know whether we should take Myrtle literally, or add our own interpretation of what she meant.

    ReplyDelete